Showing posts with label death. Show all posts
Showing posts with label death. Show all posts

Saturday, November 27, 2010

Who has inspired you?



I am a physician in no small part due to the influence of one individual. My Grandmother, LaNere Gilligan, always told me that I would be a great physician, and as we all know, it is very difficult to doubt the truth of our grandmothers. From as early as I can remember, she told me that I would become a physician, and that I would be a good physician. I never doubted what she said, and really never wavered from this idea, this goal.

She came from a much more practical time in the world. She was born in 1916 , Woodrow Wilson had been nominated during the Democratic National Convention, and WWI was raging in Europe, the United States was not to enter until one year later. She was the youngest of five, a child of the depression, for whom her parents died when she was young. She grew up in Austin Texas being raised by her eldest sister. She met my grandfather in Junior High and dated him through college. They were married in 1939. She studied nursing a Seaton School of Nursing in Austin Texas, and practiced as a nurse for many years. Many things influenced her life, and subsequently mine, but her time during the depression and her life as nurse were the things I remember the most.

From the Depression, she gained a sense of frugality. She always planned for the worst, expecting that things could decline as they had done when she was young. This frugality was something that my Grandfather had never known, he was the son of a drag-line operator, and his father always had work in the coal region of Indiana. LaNere, knew hunger, and knew early that she was an extra mouth to feed, one that was not yet able to pay her own way. This drove her toward self-sufficiency, and in that time this meant secretarial work or nursing.

Nursing was very different in the 1930’s, as was medicine. It was a time when great discoveries still lay ahead, penicillin had only come to light in 1928, and the use of certain advance surgical techniques (electrocautery) were just beginning in surgery. It was a time a paternalistic medicine. She learned her craft during this time and it influenced her interactions with physicians from that point forward. She was of an age that did not question the physician, right or wrong that was the time. She learned many skills from this environment, one of which was to encourage behavior she wanted indirectly, and this she used to great effect on me, in my youth, as she molded me into a physician.

This influence came in many forms, from the first anatomy book at an early age (pop-up), to a Gray’s Anatomy for Christmas. She encouraged exploration and investigation in all things, there was never a wrong answer, just a conclusion that needed more work. As well, there was the need to ensure the well rounded nature of her young pupil, indeed of the young physician. Lessons hard learned from an earlier time had to be passed on, and an appreciation for the lives of others must be instilled. These she did without my even knowing or seeing. Understanding of our shared past, from whence we came (the family history as it were) should be learned so that you would be grounded for the future.

As with all things, the time comes when those who influence our lives pass on from our view. Their care and concerns, the lessons learned are instilled deeply in our lives, so much so that they live on within our hearts and minds. The influences they have laid upon us are so subtle and so deep that we can hardly see where they end and we ourselves begin, they simply are part of who we have become. These influences carry us forward and help make us who we are. So, on this day, as I reflect on the life on LaNere Gilligan, one of the most influential people in my life, I send my thanks to her for all that she taught me, for the unending support and for the steadfast belief in what I could become even when I doubted myself. May I always act in a manner befitting this legacy, as may we all.


LaNere Gilligan (Thornberry) June 5, 1916-November 27, 2010

Sunday, December 6, 2009

Do the right thing.......


There has been a profound change in my practice since I left Texas, hospice and palliative care have become a very significant portion of my practice. This change has left me with deep questions regarding the practice of medicine, and has left me considering the obligation to ‘Do the right thing’.

When the focus of your practice is to diagnose and treat with an eye toward recovery, the right thing is a bit more obvious. Your charge is to figure out what is ailing the patient and make it right as quickly as you can with the least amount of harm to the patient. It is a balancing act between beneficence and harm. Harm comes in many forms, cost (for unnecessary tests), radiation (CT scans), pain (invasive tests), misdiagnosis (finding the wrong thing, or finding something incidentally that leads you on a goose chase), and side effects (every treatment has a risk). You are always balancing this against the good you are working to accomplish, asking yourself if these things are really needed in order to help the patient heal.

How does this change when your role is to help someone have a ‘good death’? The purpose is no longer recovery, but to comfort, and that changes the equation. Comfort care seems very straight forward when presented as such. You provide care to the patient that brings them comfort, relieves their suffering, and makes them at ease. At first glance this does not appear to be that difficult, and in many cases it is not. The symptoms that the patients have are such that they can be managed without any direct risk to their well being and care is provided with a minimum of risk.

When pain is a significant symptom, then the situation changes, the risks increase and the chance of harm is ever present. Most patients fear the suffering associated with pain. Pain is a great teacher; it is there to keep us alive. Pain is there to make us release the hot object, struggle against the trap, fight against the darkness. Pain is an intrinsic element of humanity, it is the great equalizer. The treatment of pain is a first order priority in the care of the hospice patient. In the minds of many, the control of pain is essential to a ‘good death’. The unfortunate risk involved in the treatment of pain is the hastening of death. The medications that are used to treat pain, narcotics primarily, all have side effects that include depression of the respiratory system, that is, they slow your breathing, sometimes fatally. The inclusion of anti-anxiety medications often makes the respiratory problem worse, and unfortunately many people have a great deal of anxiety as they approach death.

How do you balance this equation, providing for the comfort and care, but avoiding the ultimate harm? It is easier when the patient looks you in the eye and tells you what to do “I do not want to suffer, and I do not care if the medicine makes me die sooner”. But what of the patient who asks you to “Do what you think is best”. What is best? How can you know? What is best for this patient? Do you work to relieve the suffering knowing you are shortening their life? If that time is but a few hours you might not worry, but what if it is a few days, a few weeks? What if the treatment you provide gives complications that increase the suffering of the family? How do you balance these equations?

Currently the province of Quebec is having a vigorous debate on euthanasia (
CBC, Forum, Government). This debate is also happening in Europe on a larger scale (BBC , Research Article) and in the United States as well (Grid on Legal Efforts by state, Annals of Internal Medicine ). I suspect this debate will continue throughout my lifetime as it has throughout the lives of others. However, my question for now remeains, when does the provision of care and relief of suffering cross that line, and how will I know if I am doing the right thing?